Natural Health & Wellness

Whether You Buy or Bake Them, We’ve Got The Best Pure Vanilla Cookie Choices For You!

Whether You Buy or Bake Them, We’ve Got The Best Pure Vanilla Cookie Choices For You!

Do you love the taste of pure vanilla cookies? If so, you’re going to want to read this post. We’ve done the research and found the best brands of pure vanilla cookies to buy. These cookies do not have anything else in them. No nuts, no pieces of anything to distract from the warm, sweet flavor that only pure vanilla can produce.

We also found a couple of delectable and easy recipe videos from the pros for you to follow if you want to make a batch warm out of the oven to share (or not). So whether you’re looking for a classic pure vanilla icebox cookie or more of a puffier vanilla wafer, we’ve got you covered.  Plus, we’ve included two amazing recipe videos for those of you who want to make your own at home! Keep reading for all the details.  

First, if making a batch of cookies is inconvenient or not practical for you at the moment, these cookie choices have been made with love by others and will surely score big points for hitting the “Vanilla Goodness” scale.

We did the research so you don’t have to. We looked for quality ingredients (organic if possible), a short ingredient list, and rave reviews. We have also tried all of these, but not all at once! OK, maybe we did try them all at once. 🙂

Here are the best 3 that we found!

1. Newman’s Own Vanilla Creme Filled Vanilla Cookie

Newmans Own Organics Vanilla Creme Filled Vanilla Cookie TheWellthieone
Newmans Own Organics Vanilla Cookie

What we love about Newman-O’s Pure Vanilla Creme Filled Cookies:

  • Organic sugar
  • Organic flour
  • Short ingredient list of items that can be pronounced
  • Delicious! Hard to eat just one…
  • Highly rated on Amazon

2. 365 by Whole Foods Market, Cookie Animal Vanilla Organic, 11 Ounce

365 by Whole Foods Market, Cookie Animal Vanilla Organic TheWellthieone
365 Cookie Animal Vanilla Organic

What we love about these 365 Whole Foods Market Animal Cookies:

  • Organic ingredients
  • Shorter ingredient list
  • Ingredients are simple, able to be pronounced
  • Cute animal shapes
  • Delicious! Easily eaten by the handful…
  • Highly rated on Amazon

3. Homefree Mini Vanilla Cookies, Gluten Free

Homefree Mini Vanilla Cookies, Gluten Free, Nut Free, Vegan TheWellthieone
Homefree Mini Vanilla Cookies

What we love about Home Free Pure Vanilla Cookies:

  • High quality ingredients
  • Short ingredient list of pure ingredients
  • Allergen free 
  • Crunchy and delicious
  • Easy to eat way more than you planned…
  • Gluten free
  • Highly rated on Amazon

Bake Your Own Pure Vanilla Cookies

If you would like to turn on the oven, and whip up a batch of amazing pure vanilla cookies with a professional chef to guide you, we’ve got Oh Yum With Anna Olson to show you how to make simple, crisp pure vanilla cookies here:

How about baking up a batch of some Pure Vanilla Wafers?  

You can follow along step by step with Marietta Etcetera as she bakes her pure vanilla wafer recipe:

We hope we were able to satisfy your desire for the best pure vanilla cookies!The recipes show you that they are easy to bake as the ingredients are simple and usually on hand. And when you don’t have time to bake, you’ve got some great alternatives that were made with love by someone else.

The links used on are affiliate links, which may provide a small commission. This does not increase the price of the goods for the consumer whatsoever. What it does is ensure that useful content like this can continue to be produced. Thank-you for enjoying our content and allowing us to continue to provide more.

Teacher, Real Estate Investor
Every article that you read on The Wellthie One is carefully researched to provide only the best information, angles, products and advice based on experience. The top priority at The Wellthie One is enabling others to discover how living a more natural lifestyle can uplevel their quality of life. No one is going to care more about your health and the well-being of your family than you are. Education about natural health is to be on-going! Consider The Wellthie One a welcoming place for you to visit often, as you find solutions and recommendations that will help you and your loved ones thrive!